The court ordered… the court to consider the case of the “Monster House” in Podil

Популярне

Quarantine to extended until mid-May in Ukraine, libraries and museums will open

On Tuesday, April 21, the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine held a regular briefing on the situation with counteracting...

Kyiv City Council is promptly considering a comprehensive plan for construction on the lake

A new comprehensive territory plan of Bilychi micro-district was introduced in the Department of urban planning and architecture of...

New Ukraine’s government clarifications: in elevator -with mask, fine up to 34K hryvna without mask

The Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine has provided clarifications to carry ID cards, where is it necessary to wear...

The case of the so-called “Monster House” in Podil, which became a landmark for the capital. Here is everything that characterizes the new construction in the center of Kyiv: “extra” floors, “cheated” investors, non-existent agreements and a bunch of courts. Thus, after seven years of wandering in the courts, the Supreme Court ordered… to begin consideration of the case on the merits.

Excavations of the ancient underground

History of the “Monster House” on the street. Nyzhniy Val 27-29 dates back long before the first court hearing in the case, which took place back in 2014. Thus, three years earlier, the Ministry of Culture of Ukraine (MinCult) issued a permit for archaeological research at the corner of streets Konstantinovskaya and Nizhniy Val, where the future “monster” was to appear. The flavour of the situation was added by the fact that in this place  Petrovsky-Krasnoarmeyskaya (“blue”) line of the capital’s subway passes.

Excavations over the underground line ended with the construction of an elite residential complex

Here, among the historical buildings of the past  centuries, it was constructed in an open way, dismantling the historical buildings and leaving a “gap” among the dense buildings on the surface. Such a “gap” attracted the attention of the future developer – the company “Patel Leasing”.

Kaleidoscope of courts

Archaeological excavations of the underground line were quickly completed and the construction of a commercial office building began. Initially, it was a 9-storey building with one attic apartment, but during construction the house changed its occupancy (from office to residential) and storeys – from 7 plus attic to 9 and even 11 floors plus attic. These disturbances were no longer supported by the Ministry of Culture and the developer did not receive the appropriate approval for completion, which later became one of the grounds for the lawsuit.

“Monster House” was added to three times and became the highest building in the low-rise historic Podil

In 2014, the Kyiv City Council sued the developer and even, with the substantial support of the local community, managed to win the first instance in the Commercial Court of Kyiv. Consideration of the case then amounted to 5 years! However, such a long-awaited decision was soon appealed. The Northern Commercial Court of Appeal ruled that the case did not fall within the jurisdiction of the commercial courts at all. The Kyiv City Council and Kyiv residents did not agree with this. Therefore, this decision was also appealed, and on January 21, the Commercial Court of Cassation of the Supreme Court passed a Resolution, according to  which obliged the appellate court to begin consideration of the case on the merits.

Lucky pause

It will be recalled that the decision of the appeal court that the case has a different, non-commercial jurisdiction. So while this, to put it mildly, unobvious decision of the Kyiv City Council and the community was being appealed in the Supreme Court, the developer did not twiddle thumbs. Thus, development company Patelle Leasing , taking advantage of the conclusion that the dispute over the legality of the completion of “extra” floors to the jurisdiction of commercial courts, opened a “second front” in the well-known District Administrative Court of Kyiv.

The developer asked the court nothing less than to oblige the State Architectural and Construction Inspectorate to issue him a operational readiness certificate for the three times rebuilt building! But that’s not all !! Taking advantage of the confusion in the legal status of the unfinished object (in fact the decision of the appeal court on the improper consideration  negated all the conclusions of the court of first instance, in particular on the illegality of the building), the top floors investors began to register their relatives and even children at the apartments.

The Supreme Court ordered the lower court to still consider the case on the merits, instead of transferring it to other jurisdictions.

The last procedure served as an argument of the developer to close the business case and demand the transfer of the case to the third branch of justice – civil. However, after hearing the point of view of the developer’s lawyer on the provisions of the Convention on the Rights of the Child and providing a brief summary: “Did these children” settle “there before or after the trial?” during the proceedings the Presiding Judge  of the High Commercial Court of Ukraine as part of he Supreme Court Yuriy Chumak resolved: “The case should be referred to the Northern Commercial Appeal Court  for further consideration on the merits.”

Read also “The court legalized the estates of ex-regional Yura Yenakiievskyi. Yukos Oil Company case against Russia helped ”

Translated by Ilona Veretelnyk

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -

Український бренд одягу

- Advertisement -

Обмен Валют

Найновіше

Two NAU dormitories were transferred to private individuals using forged documents

The press service of the prosecutor's Office of the Kyiv city reported that law enforcement agencies are trying to...

- Advertisement -

Слідуйте за успіхом разом із нами! Кваліфіковані юридичні послуги

Embezzlement of $13 million was revealed during the construction of the Velyka Okruzhna road

The press service of the prosecutor's office of the city of Kyiv reported on the establishment of the fact of violation of state interests...

By forged documents, the entrepreneur took possession of two premises on Hrushevskoho Street​

The press service of the Kyiv Prosecutor's office informs about sending to the court an indictment on the fact of fraudulent seizure of two...

The bank provided a credit for UAH 11 million for a non-existent property

The Prosecutor's Office of Kyiv city sent to the court an indictment against the head of a private enterprise, who is suspected of seizing...

Experts comment on the government’s restriction of support of the Export Credit Agency project

On the 3rd of February in the first reading Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine passed the bill №3793 “On making amends to the Law of...

Думай

Experts comment on the government’s restriction of support of the Export Credit Agency project

On the 3rd of February in the first reading Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine passed the bill №3793 “On making...

Читай

Embezzlement of $13 million was revealed during the construction of the Velyka Okruzhna road

The press service of the prosecutor's office of the city of Kyiv reported on the establishment of the fact...

Теж цікаво

Блоги

Alina DEMCHYK | Protecting the rights of victims of domestic violence

Domestic violence is one of the most urgent social problems affecting Ukrainian society. Statistics show that about 1.8 million Ukrainian women experience domestic violence...

Andriy ZABLOVSKY | Big Data market in Ukraine or how not to miss your chance?

According to IBM Research, 90% of all human data has only appeared in the last 10 years. At this rate of data generation, in...

Andriy HREBONKIN | National Economic Strategy 2030: Future changes coming to the construction sector

At the end of 2020, the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine published the National Economic Strategy 2030, which is considered a fundamental roadmap for...

Andrii ZABLOVSKYI | Artificial intelligence technologies serving for “smart cities”: Ukraine and the world

Technologies developed on the basis of artificial intelligence are widely used for the needs of “smart cities”: starting with traffic handling (such as in...

Andrii ZABLOVSKYI | How the Law №466-IX should not be “improved” or why attempts at its “cosmetic” revision do not help

Despite numerous appeals from business and the expert community, the scandalous tax draft №1210, which entrepreneurs called "tax terror", became Law №466-IX and came...
- -